Service experience - not so great

Loki

New member
Hi all,

I took my 400 Sport into the local main dealer for its 3 year service, an MOT and an investigation into a squeaking noise yesterday morning before 9am. I received a phone call from the dealer around 4pm saying that they'd done the service but hadn't had time to perform the MOT or investigation. I told them I was happy to leave it overnight with them. I then received another call around lunchtime today in which I was told that they couldn't do the MOT as the car would fail due to a rear tyre being 1.5mm. They also could not begin the investigation as they could not therefore drive the car on the road. Since they could only provide me with (very expensive) P Zeroes, I went, paid my service bill and picked the car up.

I have several points that I'm not particularly happy about:
- Surely they would have known about the tyre when they performed the service and eVHC, so why not tell me on Thursday?
- The car *was* taken for a test drive at 17:52 yesterday evening for 2 miles according to InControl; the garage did not mention this at all. This seems to have been performed after eVHC where they deemed the tyre illegal.
- The eVHC states that the tread depth on the tyre is 2mm on the outer and middle and 1.5mm on the inner. The service invoice states that the rear n/s tyre is 2mm. Having looked at the tyre (eyeballs only), the wear markers are still ever so slightly lower than the surrounding tread on the inner edge of that tyre. I'm not convinced about their measuring to be honest.
- When I purchased the car (from that dealer) last September, the car had to have had at least 3.96mm of tread on all tyres (Jag Approved Used Checklist). The car has done 3000 miles (give or take around 30 miles) since then. This means that I would have worn off around 2.5mm of rubber in 3000 miles. I do not spin the wheels (purposely) and have never driven with traction control on (coward, I know!). When I mentioned this to the guy he told me that the wheels often spin when people leave the forecourt and this was even more likely since I "have the more powerful one" :roll:
- I received no eVHC video.
- The car was not cleaned (only mention this since it's on the Jaguar website as something they do, but apprently don't!).
- I could not have a courtsey car (apparently due to Covid measures, so perhaps fair enough)

Am I being a whingey git who should shut up and look forward to two new Michelins on Tuesday, or do I have point that the service is not great?

TIA
 
Tyre wear.....not worth getting upset about for a few reasons:

1. The accuracy of measurement to the nearest mm round the whole 360 degrees of a tyre is dodgy at best!
2. It is totally possible to “use” 5mm of tyre tread in a few hundred miles, let alone a few thousand....especially as you say, traction control wasn’t on (I think you meant off)
3. Tyres are a consumable....get over it, buy good replacements and then only you are responsible for their demise!

Jags eat tyres.....fact!
 
Loki, save your energy and fire these questions at your dealer and let us know how you get on.

If you don;t get any joy, name and shame 'em!

Bit late now I know, but never, ever buy anything from a Jag dealer, it'll cost you the earth.
 
I'd never submit my car for an MOT if the tyres had that little tread on - they're dangeroulsy low if they've got to 2mm. Pointless not checking beforehand so you can avoid an MOT fail.
 
scm said:
I'd never submit my car for an MOT if the tyres had that little tread on - they're dangeroulsy low if they've got to 2mm. Pointless not checking beforehand so you can avoid an MOT fail.

Totally agree with this point. Putting a car in for an mot with anything known as marginal that results in a fail is a real error. It’s history is marked forever online to be seen by all.

If I were OP I certainly wouldn’t whip up such a lot of worry about a sequence of events that made the dealer experience not so good. Such things are part of life..
Throw some Michelin’s on get out and enjoy scrubbing some tread off over the next few thousand miles
 
I collected my 400 sport today after 4 days in for 3rd service, MOT and some investigations.

The service was done first with the video health check. Day 2 was MOT first (it passed because I checked everything I could before it went - old school from MOT'ing older cars previously) and investigations. My squeak was down to exhaust and its had a complete new back box.

After brake fluid change, transfer box fluid change and updated software to stop that lurch when selecting D from P it feels like a new car again.

Still got to go back for SOTA updates, drivers seat and a trim issue but really happy with dealer.

They seem to do things in a certain order/process as it passes through their service centre so failing an MOT after a service to them would be normal. I personally wouldn't take a car for an MOT with barely legal tyres as its always going to come back as a fail/advisory and running a tyre at 1.5mm is not safe at all.

I would file your comments to the dealer, they might offer some reductions on future work as goodwill.
 
Back
Top